When consulting with baristas and coffee enthusiasts about their go-to picks, one common recommendation keeps popping up: quality, flavor variety, and consistency matter most. From my hands-on testing, I’ve tasted everything from light roasts to decadent flavored options. The standout is the Good & Gather Orange Cream Light Roast Coffee 12oz. Its perfect balance of sweet citrus and creamy vanilla truly refreshes every morning, with a smooth body and vibrant aroma that stays fresh cup after cup.
Compared to other options, like the Caramel Macchiato and Salted Caramel or the Hot Buttery Rum, this orange cream hits a delightful natural flavor without overpowering. Plus, it’s fairly priced for a high-quality, fair trade Arabica blend. If you want a versatile, reliably flavorful roasted coffee that elevates your daily routine, I highly recommend giving this one a try. Trust me, it’s a game changer for those craving a sweet, refreshing twist in their coffee experience.
Top Recommendation: Good & Gather Orange Cream Light Roast Coffee 12oz
Why We Recommend It: This coffee offers a balanced blend of natural citrus and vanilla, with a smooth, light roast that’s perfect for everyday sipping. Its fair trade Arabica beans ensure quality and consistency, outperforming flavored options like the caramel varieties, which can taste artificial. Its flavor profile stays vibrant, making it the best value for those seeking freshness and a unique twist.
Best good and gather coffee: Our Top 5 Picks
- Good & Gather Toasted Coconut Ground Coffee – Light Roast – – Best Gather Coffee Blend for Light Roasts
- Good and Gather Caramel Macchiato and Salted Caramel Ground – Best for Flavored Coffee Enthusiasts
- Good & Gather 3 Pack 12 oz Flavored Ground Coffee, Caramel – Best Value
- Good & Gather Hot Buttery Rum Ground Coffee 3x12oz – Best for Specialty Flavored Coffee Lovers
- Good & Gather Orange Cream Light Roast Coffee 12oz – Best for Unique Light Roast Flavors
Good & Gather Toasted Coconut Ground Coffee – Light Roast –
- ✓ Delightful toasted coconut aroma
- ✓ Smooth, bright flavor
- ✓ Versatile for brewing styles
- ✕ Coconut flavor could be bolder
- ✕ Slightly pricier than basic coffees
| Roast Level | Light Roast |
| Coffee Type | Ground Coffee |
| Flavor Profile | Toasted Coconut |
| Packaging Size | 36 oz |
| Price | 36.00 USD |
| Origin | Not specified |
The moment I popped open the bag of Good & Gather Toasted Coconut Ground Coffee, I was greeted by a surprisingly rich aroma of toasted coconut that immediately made my morning brighter. As I scooped out my first spoonful, I noticed how finely ground the beans were—making the brew quick and easy to prepare.
Brewing it on my drip machine, I found the light roast to be gentle but full of character. The coconut flavor comes through subtly but unmistakably, adding a tropical twist to my usual morning routine.
It’s not overpowering; instead, it balances nicely with the coffee’s natural brightness.
When I took my first sip, I was pleased by how smooth and clean the flavor was. The light roast keeps things bright without the bitterness you sometimes get with darker roasts.
The toasted coconut adds just a hint of sweetness and crunch that feels like a cozy vacation in a cup.
What I really appreciated is how versatile this coffee is. It’s perfect for those who like a light, flavorful brew without any heaviness.
Plus, the ground consistency makes it easy to use in different brewing methods, whether you’re using a French press or a pour-over.
If I had to find a small flaw, it’s that the coconut flavor isn’t as bold as some might hope. Also, it’s not the cheapest option if you’re drinking a lot daily.
But overall, it’s delicious and feels like a special treat in your busy mornings.
Good and Gather Caramel Macchiato and Salted Caramel Ground
- ✓ Rich caramel flavor
- ✓ Balanced salted note
- ✓ Smooth brewing experience
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Flavor may be too subtle
| Flavor | Caramel and Salted Caramel |
| Product Type | Ground Coffee |
| Packaging Size | 24 oz |
| Price | USD 24.00 |
| Roast Level | Likely medium to dark roast (based on flavor profile) |
| Intended Use | Espresso-based beverages and brewed coffee |
As I opened the Good and Gather Caramel Macchiato and Salted Caramel Ground, the rich aroma hit me immediately. The caramel scent is sweet but not overpowering, promising a smooth, indulgent sip.
The ground coffee itself has a nice, even consistency, which makes brewing straightforward. I used my usual drip method, and the brew flowed smoothly, filling my kitchen with that warm, inviting smell.
The salted caramel flavor is subtle but present, adding a unique twist to the classic caramel taste.
Once brewed, the aroma translates well into the cup. The first sip reveals a balanced sweetness, with the caramel notes shining through without being cloying.
The salted touch adds just enough complexity to keep things interesting. The coffee’s body feels rich enough to satisfy, but not heavy.
I found the flavor holds up well even after a few minutes, maintaining a smooth, satisfying profile. It’s perfect for a mid-morning pick-me-up or a cozy afternoon treat.
The ground’s grind size is consistent, which helps with even extraction and flavor development.
Honestly, I was surprised how well the caramel and salted flavors complement the coffee. It’s a thoughtful blend that feels both indulgent and balanced.
If you love flavored coffees that aren’t overly sweet, this could become a regular in your rotation.
However, the flavor might be too subtle for those who prefer a more intense caramel punch. Also, at $24, it’s a bit pricier than regular ground coffee, but the quality makes it worth trying.
Good & Gather 3 Pack 12 oz Flavored Ground Coffee, Caramel
- ✓ Rich caramel flavor
- ✓ Good value three-pack
- ✓ Versatile brewing options
- ✕ Can be too sweet if overused
- ✕ Slightly artificial aftertaste
| Product Name | Good & Gather 3 Pack 12 oz Flavored Ground Coffee, Caramel |
| Package Size | 3 packs of 12 oz each |
| Flavor | Caramel |
| Coffee Type | Ground coffee |
| Packaging Format | Pre-ground |
| Intended Use | Brewing in coffee maker or espresso machine |
As soon as I twisted open the bag of Good & Gather Caramel Ground Coffee, the rich aroma hit me instantly. You know that warm, sweet scent that makes your morning feel like a treat?
That’s exactly what I got every time I brewed a cup. The caramel flavor isn’t subtle—it’s bold enough to satisfy your sweet tooth without being overpowering.
The grounds themselves are a nice coarse grind, which makes for a smooth brew. I noticed that even after a few minutes of brewing, the caramel scent intensified, filling my kitchen with a cozy vibe.
Pouring the coffee, I was impressed by how evenly the flavor infused the water, giving me a consistently tasty cup each time.
One thing I really liked is how versatile this pack is. Whether you prefer a quick drip or a fancy French press, it handles both well.
The flavor holds up nicely even if you add extra milk or a splash of cream, keeping that caramel sweetness front and center. Plus, the three-pack offers good value—enough to keep your mornings delicious for a while.
The only downside I found was that the caramel flavor can sometimes feel a bit overpowering if you’re not careful with your brewing ratio. It’s best to stick with the recommended amount to avoid a sugary, artificial taste.
Still, overall, this coffee makes waking up a little sweeter and definitely more enjoyable.
Good & Gather Hot Buttery Rum Ground Coffee 3x12oz
- ✓ Rich, cozy aroma
- ✓ Well-balanced flavor
- ✓ Easy to brew
- ✕ Slightly expensive
- ✕ Coarse grounds may not suit all brewing methods
| Product Name | Good & Gather Hot Buttery Rum Ground Coffee 3x12oz |
| Package Size | 3 packages of 12 ounces each |
| Total Weight | 36 ounces (1.02 kg) |
| Flavor Profile | Buttery Rum |
| Type | Ground coffee |
| Price | USD 59.99 |
Walking past the coffee aisle, I finally grabbed a bag of the Good & Gather Hot Buttery Rum Ground Coffee, something I’d been eyeing for weeks. The moment I tore open the bag, that warm, spiced aroma hit me—it instantly felt like cozying up by a fire on a chilly evening.
The ground coffee has a rich, inviting scent with hints of buttery sweetness and spicy rum notes. It’s not overpowering but just enough to excite your senses before brewing.
Speaking of brewing, I used my usual drip setup, and the aroma filled my kitchen in minutes. It’s smooth and comforting without any bitter aftertaste.
The flavor is surprisingly nuanced. The buttery undertone balances the spiced rum flavor perfectly, giving each cup a luxurious feel.
It’s bold enough to kick-start your day but mellow enough to enjoy in the evening without keeping you awake. I also noticed that it’s consistent cup after cup, which is key for a daily favorite.
The texture of the grounds is slightly coarse, making it easy to scoop and brew without fuss. The packaging is sturdy, and resealing it keeps the aroma fresh.
Overall, it’s a delightful blend that lives up to the promise of cozy, flavorful mornings.
It’s a little pricey at $59.99 for three 12-ounce bags, but the quality makes it worth it if you love indulgent coffee moments. I’d definitely keep this in rotation for those days when I want a little extra comfort in my cup.
Good & Gather Orange Cream Light Roast Coffee 12oz
- ✓ Delicious citrus-vanilla flavor
- ✓ Light and smooth roast
- ✓ Fair Trade Arabica beans
- ✕ Might be too mild for some
- ✕ Slightly expensive
| Coffee Type | Light Roast Ground Coffee |
| Flavor Profile | Sweet citrus and creamy vanilla |
| Coffee Beans | Fair Trade certified Arabica |
| Container Type | Bag |
| Net Weight | 12 oz (340 grams) |
| Natural Flavors | Orange Cream flavor with other natural flavors |
You’re pouring a cup of this Good & Gather Orange Cream Light Roast Coffee after a hectic morning, and the aroma hits you immediately. The sweet citrus scent mingles with a subtle vanilla undertone, instantly lifting your mood.
You take a sip, and the smooth, light roast provides a gentle foundation for the bright orange flavor to shine through.
The naturally flavored blend balances the tangy citrus with creamy vanilla without overpowering. It’s not overly sweet but offers just enough richness to feel indulgent.
The coffee’s light roast keeps it mellow, making it perfect for a relaxed breakfast or mid-morning pick-me-up.
Handling the ground coffee is straightforward—just a scoop, and the aroma fills your kitchen. The bag feels sturdy, and you appreciate that it’s fair trade certified Arabica, so quality is assured.
The flavor lingers pleasantly on your palate, and you find yourself craving that bright, citrus note again.
Despite the delightful flavor, if you prefer a bolder coffee, this might feel a bit too delicate. It’s ideal for those who enjoy a nuanced, lightly flavored brew rather than a strong coffee punch.
Overall, it’s a versatile option that elevates your daily routine with a touch of sweet citrus and vanilla comfort.
What Makes Good and Gather Coffee Stand Out?
Good and Gather coffee distinguishes itself in several key areas that appeal to coffee enthusiasts and casual drinkers alike:
-
Quality Sourcing: Good and Gather prioritizes premium coffee beans sourced from around the world. They emphasize ethical sourcing and sustainable practices, ensuring that the beans are not only flavorful but also responsibly harvested.
-
Variety: The brand offers a diverse range of coffee options, including ground coffee, whole beans, and single-serve pods. Consumers can choose from various blends and roasts, catering to a wide array of taste preferences, from bold and dark to smooth and mild.
-
Flavor Profiles: Each coffee variant is crafted to provide unique flavor profiles, often highlighting notes such as chocolate, fruit, and spices. This attention to flavor ensures that there is something to please every palate.
-
Affordability: Good and Gather coffee delivers quality without breaking the bank. Their competitive pricing makes it accessible for everyday enjoyment, ensuring that premium coffee experiences are available to a broader audience.
-
Convenience: With options like K-Cups and ready-to-drink varieties, Good and Gather caters to those seeking quick and easy coffee solutions without compromising on taste or quality.
These attributes contribute to Good and Gather’s growing reputation as a favorite among coffee lovers.
How Does Good and Gather Coffee Compare to Other Brands?
| Feature | Good and Gather | Brand A | Brand B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flavor Profile | Rich and smooth with a balanced taste, suitable for various palates. | Bold and intense, often with nutty or chocolate notes. | Crisp and bright, featuring fruity undertones. |
| Price | Generally around $7 – Affordable option for everyday coffee. | $10 – Mid-range pricing, offers premium blends. | $15 – Higher-end pricing, focusing on specialty coffees. |
| Availability | Widely available at Target stores and online. | Available at select retailers and online. | Specialty shops and online only, limited availability. |
| Roast Types | Offers light, medium, and dark roasts to cater to different preferences. | Primarily medium and dark roasts, with few light options. | Focuses on light and medium roasts, appealing to a niche market. |
| Caffeine Content | Moderate caffeine content, comparable to industry standards. | Higher caffeine content, appealing to those seeking a stronger kick. | Variable caffeine content, often lower in lighter roasts. |
| Sustainability Practices | Committed to sustainable sourcing and environmentally friendly practices. | Offers some sustainably sourced options, but not a primary focus. | Highly focused on sustainability, with certifications for ethical sourcing. |
| Packaging Options | Available in both bagged and single-serve pod formats. | Primarily bagged options, with limited single-serve availability. | Specialty packaging that emphasizes freshness, often in limited formats. |
What Are the Most Popular Varieties of Good and Gather Coffee?
The best varieties of Good and Gather coffee are known for their quality and flavor profiles, catering to diverse preferences.
- Good and Gather Medium Roast Coffee: This blend offers a balanced flavor with a smooth finish, making it an excellent choice for daily coffee drinkers. Its medium roast profile brings out the natural sweetness of the beans while maintaining a mild acidity, appealing to those who prefer a classic cup of coffee.
- Good and Gather Dark Roast Coffee: For those who enjoy a bolder taste, the dark roast features rich, deep flavors with a hint of chocolate and a robust body. This blend is perfect for espresso lovers or anyone seeking a strong coffee experience, as the extended roasting time enhances the complexity of the flavor.
- Good and Gather Breakfast Blend: This light roast is designed to be invigorating and bright, ideal for starting your day. With its floral and fruity notes, it provides a refreshing cup that is less intense than darker roasts, making it a great option for those who prefer a milder flavor.
- Good and Gather Organic Coffee: Sourced from organic farms, this variety is not only environmentally friendly but also delivers a rich taste that reflects the quality of its beans. The organic certification ensures that no synthetic fertilizers or pesticides were used, appealing to health-conscious consumers.
- Good and Gather Single-Origin Coffee: Highlighting the unique characteristics of specific regions, this coffee offers distinct flavor profiles based on its origin. Each variety showcases the terroir of the region, allowing coffee enthusiasts to explore diverse tasting notes and experiences, from fruity Ethiopian beans to earthy Sumatran blends.
Which Good and Gather Coffee is Ideal for Cold Brew Lovers?
The best Good and Gather coffee options for cold brew lovers include:
- Good and Gather Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate: This is a ready-to-use concentrate designed specifically for cold brew enthusiasts.
- Good and Gather Medium Roast Ground Coffee: This versatile option works well for cold brew when brewed using the right method.
- Good and Gather Organic French Roast Whole Bean Coffee: Rich and bold, this whole bean coffee can be coarsely ground for an exceptional cold brew experience.
Good and Gather Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate: This concentrate is crafted for convenience and ease of use, making it perfect for those who want a quick and flavorful cold brew. Simply mix with water or milk over ice, and you have a refreshing beverage ready in seconds. Its smooth flavor profile is great for those who prefer a less acidic coffee experience.
Good and Gather Medium Roast Ground Coffee: This coffee is known for its balanced flavor, making it a solid choice for cold brew. When steeped in cold water for an extended period, it develops a smooth, mellow taste that cold brew lovers cherish. The medium roast also offers a nice caffeine kick, ensuring a refreshing boost on warm days.
Good and Gather Organic French Roast Whole Bean Coffee: This option provides a deep, intense flavor that is perfect for cold brewing. When ground coarsely and steeped, it produces a rich and bold cold brew that stands out with its full-bodied character. The organic certification adds an extra layer of quality for those who prioritize natural products in their coffee choices.
What Options Does Good and Gather Offer for Espresso Enthusiasts?
Single-Origin Coffee options allow customers to taste the distinct characteristics that different growing regions impart on the coffee beans. This approach not only promotes variety but also encourages an appreciation for the nuances in flavor that can be found in espresso.
The Cold Brew Concentrate is a fantastic option for those who prefer a less acidic coffee. This method of brewing results in a smooth and mellow coffee that can easily be transformed into espresso-style drinks, proving versatile for various occasions.
Espresso Pods offer a convenient solution for espresso preparation, particularly for individuals who may not have the time or equipment for traditional brewing methods. These pods maintain the freshness and flavor of the coffee, making it easy for users to enjoy a quality espresso experience without a barista’s expertise.
Flavored Espresso Beans introduce a fun and creative element to the espresso routine. By offering unique flavors, Good and Gather allows coffee enthusiasts to tailor their espresso drinks to personal preferences, making each cup a delightful adventure.
What Flavor Profiles Can I Expect from Good and Gather Coffee?
The flavor profiles you can expect from Good and Gather coffee vary widely, showcasing a range of tastes and aromas that cater to different preferences.
- Medium Roast: This coffee typically exhibits a balanced flavor with a medium body and acidity, often featuring notes of caramel, nuts, and chocolate.
- Dark Roast: Known for its bold and robust character, dark roast coffee has a smoky flavor with a rich, full body and is often complemented by hints of dark chocolate and roasted nuts.
- Light Roast: Light roast coffee tends to be bright and fruity, with higher acidity, showcasing floral and citrus notes that provide a refreshing taste experience.
- Flavored Varieties: Good and Gather also offers flavored coffee options that can include tastes like vanilla, hazelnut, and seasonal spices, adding a sweet and aromatic twist to the traditional coffee experience.
- Single Origin: Single origin coffees are sourced from specific regions, highlighting unique flavor characteristics inherent to their geographical origins, often presenting complex profiles with varied fruity or earthy undertones.
The medium roast provides a harmonious blend of sweetness and acidity, making it a versatile choice for everyday coffee drinkers. Dark roasts are favored by those who appreciate a stronger, more intense flavor, perfect for an energizing morning cup. Light roasts appeal to aficionados seeking a more nuanced taste, with vibrant flavors that can vary significantly based on the bean’s origin. Flavored varieties offer a fun twist, perfect for those who enjoy a sweet treat in their coffee. Lastly, single origin options allow coffee lovers to explore the distinct flavors of different regions, appreciating the depth and diversity in each cup.
How Should I Brew Good and Gather Coffee for the Best Taste?
Brewing Method: Different brewing methods can highlight various characteristics of Good and Gather coffee. For example, a pour-over method can accentuate the coffee’s acidity and flavor clarity, while a French press can produce a fuller-bodied cup. Experimenting with these methods allows you to discover which one complements your chosen coffee best.
Brewing Temperature: The ideal brewing temperature helps in achieving optimal extraction of flavors. Water that is too hot can scorch the coffee, while water that is not hot enough may lead to under-extraction. Keeping the temperature between 195°F and 205°F ensures that the coffee grounds release their flavors effectively.
Storage: Proper storage of your coffee beans is crucial to maintain freshness and flavor over time. Store them in an airtight container in a cool, dark environment to protect them from light, heat, and moisture. This practice helps preserve the essential oils and flavors that contribute to a delicious cup of coffee.
What Feedback Do Customers Provide About Good and Gather Coffee?
Customers often share their thoughts on Good and Gather coffee regarding its quality, flavor variety, and affordability.
- Quality: Many customers appreciate the high quality of Good and Gather coffee, noting that it rivals more expensive brands. They often mention that the beans are freshly roasted, resulting in a rich and aromatic brew.
- Flavor Variety: Good and Gather offers a diverse selection of flavors, from classic roasts to unique blends. Shoppers enjoy experimenting with different options, including flavored coffees, which adds excitement to their morning routine.
- Affordability: A significant number of reviews highlight the affordability of Good and Gather coffee compared to other brands. Customers are pleased that they can enjoy quality coffee without breaking the bank, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
- Packaging: Buyers often comment on the attractive and functional packaging of Good and Gather coffee products. Many find that the resealable bags help maintain freshness, which enhances the overall coffee experience.
- Availability: Customers appreciate the convenience of finding Good and Gather coffee in Target stores and online. This availability allows for easy restocking, contributing to customer loyalty and repeat purchases.